Published: 25 September 2026 · First edition · Corrected 1 October 2026: three outcomes and one insurer name fixed after re-reading each decision · Updated 13 October 2026: the searchable table of all 26 decisions and the data download are now on this page · Next update: December 2026
Quick answer: We read 26 published Financial Ombudsman Service decisions on pet insurance claims that insurers had refused. In 16 the ombudsman found for the pet owner, in 1 partly for the owner and in 9 for the insurer. The pattern is consistent: owners won when the insurer could not prove that a new problem was linked to an old one, when the owner could not reasonably have known something was wrong, or when the insurer had not asked clear questions at the start. Insurers won when symptoms were clearly recorded before cover began, when the problem appeared during the waiting period, when one policy limit applied to related problems, or when the owner had answered a clear question inaccurately.
How we compiled this report. We searched the Financial Ombudsman Service’s published decisions for pet insurance complaints, grouped by the reason the claim was refused: pre-existing conditions, bilateral conditions, waiting periods, time limits, exclusions and non-disclosure. We read each decision in full and recorded the insurer, the animal, the reason for refusal, the outcome and what decided it. This is not a random sample: it was chosen to cover the most common reasons for refusal, so the 16-to-9 split should not be read as a success rate for complaints in general. For context, the ombudsman reports that it upheld 30% of all complaints it resolved across all financial products in 2025/26 (Financial Ombudsman Service). Each decision is linked below so you can read it yourself.
Outcomes by reason for refusal
| Reason the claim was refused | Decisions | Owner won | Partly | Insurer won |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pre-existing / related condition | 15 | 11 | 0 | 4 |
| Time limits and same-condition rules | 4 | 2 | 1 | 1 |
| Disclosure and eligibility | 3 | 1 | 0 | 2 |
| Waiting period | 2 | 1 | 0 | 1 |
| Exclusion applied by the insurer | 2 | 1 | 0 | 1 |
| All decisions | 26 | 16 | 1 | 9 |
Where the owner won, the usual result was that the insurer had to pay or reassess the claim and add 8% simple interest. In 10 of the 16 owner wins the ombudsman also awarded £100 to £350 for distress and inconvenience; £150 was the most common amount.
Seven lessons from the decisions
1. The insurer has to prove the exclusion applies
If you show you have a valid claim, the insurer has to prove that an exclusion applies. In most of the cases the owner won, the insurer could not show that the new problem was caused by the old one. A single episode of lameness years earlier did not prove a cruciate problem (DRN-3765896, DRN-4467981), and past episodes of sickness did not prove the same underlying cause (DRN-4115911), and a time limit on heart problems could not be applied to a cough that later tests showed was not heart-related (DRN-3304706).
2. What you knew matters, not just what the notes say
The ombudsman’s long-standing approach is to ask whether you knew, or should reasonably have known, that something was wrong and likely to need treatment. Owners won where a lump or skin tag had been noted but the vet showed no concern (DRN-5872505, DRN-5521396, DRN-5396481), and where an isolated problem had been treated and resolved (DRN-4314086, DRN-5372222), and where an owner had not noticed the early signs of Cushing’s disease before cover began (DRN-3782503).
3. Your vet’s letter works when it is specific
In a two-knee cruciate case, the owner won because the vet explained that the injuries had different causes and happened more than two years apart (DRN-3613393). In another, the vet confirmed that an ulcer in one eye was unrelated to earlier problems in the other (DRN-5338068). But a vet’s letter that relied only on time passing, without tests or clinical reasoning, was described as speculative and did not succeed (DRN-5989158).
4. Answer the application questions accurately
This cuts both ways. An owner who described a vet visit for a skin lesion as “flea treatment” lost a later cancer claim, because the insurer showed it would have added an exclusion if told the truth (DRN-5568843). But where insurers could not show what they had asked, or the questions were unclear, they were not allowed to add exclusions after the event (DRN-4115911, DRN-4467981).
5. Exclusions must be applied to what actually caused the problem
An insurer refused a £1,956 cruciate claim because the dog was slightly overweight. It lost: it had not shown the weight caused the rupture, and the treating vet said it had no bearing (DRN-3551227).
6. Where insurers win
Insurers won when symptoms were clearly recorded before cover began (DRN-3555242), when the problem started in the waiting period (DRN-5061127), when the vet’s records pointed to a likely underlying cause linking the new problem to an earlier one (DRN-5390065, DRN-5989158), when one policy limit applied to related problems, as with a second problem in the same leg soon after the first (DRN-4276223, where the owner received only the balance of the limit) or surgery on both legs for the same diagnosis (DRN-5229861). Cover also failed for cats kept by a rescue, which the ombudsman found were not the owner’s personal pets (DRN-5861368).
7. What you get if you win
In 15 of the 16 cases the owner won, the ombudsman told the insurer to pay or reassess the claim and add 8% simple interest, and in 10 of the 16 it also awarded £100 to £350 for distress and inconvenience.
All 26 decisions: search and filter
| Decision | Insurer | Pet | Claimed for | Reason refused | Outcome | Compensation | Decided (approx.) | What decided it |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| DRN-5338068 | Casualty & General | Dog | Corneal ulcer in the right eye; earlier ulcers in the left eye | Pre-existing / related condition | Owner won | £100 | Apr 2025 | The vet said the two eyes were not connected and the insurer offered no veterinary evidence that they were. |
| DRN-5396481 | Casualty & General | Dog | Removal of an inflamed lump that had been present for 2-3 years | Pre-existing / related condition | Owner won | £150 | Apr 2025 | Nothing had needed treatment before the lump became inflamed, so the owner had no reason to expect it would. |
| DRN-5290537 | RSA | Cat | Hyperthyroidism and weight loss; the cat was put to sleep | Pre-existing / related condition | Owner won | £150 | Mar 2025 | The notes did not show when the weight loss began, so the insurer could not prove it started before cover. |
| DRN-4314086 | Liverpool Victoria (LV) | Dog | Left cruciate ligament operation after an earlier right cruciate injury | Pre-existing / related condition | Owner won | £150 | Oct 2023 | The two injuries followed separate falls and nothing showed an underlying disease linking them. The £150 was on top of £30 the insurer had already paid. |
| DRN-3765896 | Casualty & General | Dog | Ruptured cruciate ligament (TPLO surgery); lameness had been recorded in 2018 | Pre-existing / related condition | Owner won | £100 | Jun 2023 | The treating vet did not link the earlier lameness to the rupture. The insurer also had to remove two exclusions it had added. |
| DRN-5872505 | Intact | Dog | Removal of a skin tag first noted at a vet visit before the policy | Pre-existing / related condition | Owner won | £150 | Dec 2025 | The vet had shown no concern and the owner could not reasonably have known it would need treatment. |
| DRN-5521396 | Agria | Puppy | Removal of a mast cell tumour from the head; a spot had been seen before cover | Pre-existing / related condition | Owner won | None | Sep 2025 | Two vets had checked the spot and neither thought it a concern, so the owner had no reason to expect treatment. |
| DRN-5372222 | Direct Line (UK Insurance) | Not stated | Investigation of a suspected cruciate problem; earlier lameness in 2022 | Pre-existing / related condition | Owner won | None | Jun 2025 | The insurer could not show a link between the 2022 lameness and the current problem. |
| DRN-3551227 | Casualty & General | Dog | Cruciate ligament rupture surgery | Exclusion applied by the insurer | Owner won | None | Aug 2022 | The insurer had not shown that the dog being slightly overweight caused the rupture. |
| DRN-3613393 | NFU Mutual | Dog | Second cruciate ligament claim; the first had been claimed in 2019 | Time limits and same-condition rules | Owner won | £100 | Sep 2022 | The vet’s evidence and a gap of over two years supported treating the two injuries as separate conditions. |
| DRN-4115911 | Casualty & General | Dog | Vomiting and diarrhoea illness on a time-limited policy | Pre-existing / related condition | Owner won | None | Jun 2023 | Past episodes had not been shown to share a cause, and the insurer had not shown it asked a clear question at the outset. |
| DRN-4467981 | Casualty & General | Dog | Arthritis; leg stiffness had been seen five years earlier | Pre-existing / related condition | Owner won | None | Jan 2024 | The earlier lameness did not show arthritis and the insurer had not shown what it asked at the start. It had to reconsider the claim. |
| DRN-4027239 | HDI Global Specialty | Cat | Condition diagnosed after scans; the old policy expired a day before the owner bought a new one | Waiting period | Owner won | £150 | May 2023 | The insurer’s expiry notices were unclear, so the new policy was treated as a continuation with no new waiting period. |
| DRN-5592317 | Alwyn | Dog | Removal of a mammary tumour; policies cancelled over breeding | Disclosure and eligibility | Owner won | £100 | Oct 2025 | The policy wording looked forward and did not ask whether the dogs had ever bred, so there was no misrepresentation. |
| DRN-3782503 | Casualty & General | Dog | Cushing’s disease: tests and treatment | Pre-existing / related condition | Owner won | None | Dec 2022 | The owner had not noticed clinical signs before or just after cover began, and the Cushing’s exclusion was removed. |
| DRN-3304706 | Pinnacle | Dog | Investigations into a cough on a time-limited policy | Time limits and same-condition rules | Owner won | £350 | May 2022 | The time limit was clear, but tests later showed no heart disease, so the claim had to be reconsidered. |
| DRN-3555242 | Allianz (Petplan) | Dog | Tests after a heart murmur noted before cover started | Pre-existing / related condition | Insurer won | None | Jul 2022 | The murmur was noted before cover began, and the owner had answered no to questions about earlier signs of illness. |
| DRN-5152812 | Allianz (Petplan) | Dog | Ear and skin exclusions made permanent after a claim for an ear lump | Exclusion applied by the insurer | Insurer won | None | Jan 2025 | The ombudsman accepted that an insurer may choose which risks it covers, and the dog had several ear episodes. |
| DRN-4716911 | Casualty & General | Dog | Dental treatment for periodontal disease | Pre-existing / related condition | Insurer won | None | May 2024 | The same disease had been treated within the 24 months before cover, even though the vet said the episodes were not directly linked. |
| DRN-4276223 | Casualty & General | Dog | Cruciate rupture four months after surgery on the same leg for a dislocated kneecap | Time limits and same-condition rules | Partly upheld | None | Aug 2023 | The two problems were treated as one condition, so the £4,000 limit applied. The owner received the remaining balance with interest. |
| DRN-5229861 | Equine & Livestock (The Insurance Emporium) | Not stated | Surgery on both legs for the same diagnosis | Time limits and same-condition rules | Insurer won | None | Jan 2025 | Nothing showed a different cause in each limb, so one limit applied to a bilateral condition. |
| DRN-5061127 | Admiral | Dog | Vet fees and X-rays for spinal pain | Waiting period | Insurer won | None | Nov 2024 | The problem started within the first 14 days of the policy, and a phone call to the insurer does not guarantee that a claim will be paid. |
| DRN-5390065 | Pinnacle | Dog | Hot spot and ear infection | Pre-existing / related condition | Insurer won | None | Apr 2025 | The vet considered allergic skin disease a possible underlying cause of both, and the policy excluded related conditions. |
| DRN-5989158 | Intact | Not stated | Skin flare-up and ear infection | Pre-existing / related condition | Insurer won | None | Dec 2025 | Allergies had been discussed before cover began, and the owner’s vet letter relied on the time gap alone. |
| DRN-5568843 | Equine & Livestock | Cat | Mast cell tumour near the ear | Disclosure and eligibility | Insurer won | None | Jun 2025 | The ombudsman found the claim should not be refused as pre-existing, but the owner described a vet visit for a skin lesion as flea treatment, so a backdated exclusion was fair. |
| DRN-5861368 | Casualty & General | Cat | Claim declined and two policies voided; the owner ran an animal rescue | Disclosure and eligibility | Insurer won | None | Dec 2025 | The cats were registered under a business name and advertised for rehoming, so they were not treated as personal pets. |
Showing 26 of 26 decisions
Several insurers appear more than once because of how we searched. This report does not rank insurers, and the number of decisions about any one insurer says nothing about how often it refuses claims. “Decided (approx.)” is the month of the deadline the ombudsman gave the owner to accept or reject the decision, which usually falls a few weeks after the decision itself.
Download the data
Download all 26 decisions as a CSV file (insurer, pet, what was claimed for, reason, outcome, compensation, interest, amount where stated, and what decided each case). You are welcome to use it; please link back to this page.
Using this if your claim has been refused
- Get the refusal in writing, with the policy clause and the vet notes it relies on.
- Check whether the insurer has actually shown a link between the old problem and the new one.
- Ask your vet for a specific written opinion on whether they are connected, and why.
- Complain to the insurer; it has eight weeks to respond.
- If you’re not satisfied, refer the complaint to the Financial Ombudsman Service. It’s free.
Our step-by-step guide: pet insurance claim rejected? How to challenge it.
Frequently asked questions
How many of these pet insurance complaints did the ombudsman uphold?
In this set of 26 decisions, 16 were upheld, 1 was partly upheld and 9 were not upheld. The decisions were chosen to cover the most common reasons for refusal, so this is not a success rate for pet insurance complaints in general.
How much compensation does the ombudsman award for a refused pet insurance claim?
In the 10 owner wins that included compensation, the awards ranged from £100 to £350 for distress and inconvenience, with £150 the most common. In the other owner wins the ombudsman ordered the claim to be paid or reconsidered without compensation.
What happens after the ombudsman upholds a complaint?
In these cases the insurer was told to pay or reassess the claim, usually with 8% simple interest from the date the owner paid the vet. Each decision asks the owner to accept or reject it by a deadline; only an accepted decision binds the insurer.
Can I read the full decisions?
Yes. Every reference in the table links to the decision PDF on the Financial Ombudsman Service website.
Spotted an error?
Tell us through the contact page and we will check it against the decision and correct it.
Related guides
- Pet insurance and pre-existing conditions
- Does pet insurance cover cruciate ligament surgery?
- How pet insurance works
- Bilateral conditions explained
- How to make a pet insurance claim
This report summarises published decisions for general information. It is not legal or financial advice, and every complaint is decided on its own facts.